SCORING TRENDS

Judge statistics

Compare a band with a judge

Recorded scores110
Scored competitions11
Schools52

Only scores tied to a matching judge assignment are included; penalties are excluded. Each row compares one caption and score type, using score points. Select a caption and flight to narrow the comparison.

Difference vs other judges: for each score, compare with other judges' scores for the same school, score type, year, flight, and competitive/exhibition status at other competitions. Negative means lower than that comparison average. Matched count shows how many scores have a comparison. These describe the recorded performances; improvement over the season and different competition conditions also affect scores.

JudgeCaption / measureMaximumScoresShows / schoolsAverageHighLowMatchedDifference vs other judges
Pickett, DaveGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot20283 / 2214.85717.00012.80028 / 28+0.043
Pickett, DaveVisual - Ensemble — Tot20747 / 5015.29418.70012.80074 / 74-0.191
Pickett, DaveVisual - Individual — Tot1081 / 87.0067.5006.5008 / 8-0.526

Pickett, Dave · competition trends

Judge averages by competition and flightLines show recorded values. Gaps indicate missing scores. Exact values and competition links are in the table below.62.47768.54574.61480.68286.75Sep 30, 2023Oct 28, 2023Oct 12, 2024Oct 4, 2025Sep 26, 2026Oct 3, 2026Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight II · Sep 30, 2023 — Portage Northern Marching Band Invitational — Flight II · 68Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight II · Oct 7, 2023 — Clarkston Marching Band Invitational — Flight II · 66.5Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight II · Oct 12, 2024 — Rockford — Flight II · 77Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight II · Oct 4, 2025 — Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational — Flight II · 78.833Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight II · Oct 11, 2025 — Sparta Marching Band Invitational — Flight II · 79Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight III · Sep 30, 2023 — Portage Northern Marching Band Invitational — Flight III · 71.75Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight III · Oct 7, 2023 — Clarkston Marching Band Invitational — Flight III · 74.5Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight III · Oct 4, 2025 — Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational — Flight III · 75.833Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight III · Oct 11, 2025 — Sparta Marching Band Invitational — Flight III · 75.813Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight IV · Sep 30, 2023 — Portage Northern Marching Band Invitational — Flight IV · 67.333Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight IV · Oct 7, 2023 — Clarkston Marching Band Invitational — Flight IV · 72.5Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight IV · Oct 28, 2023 — Flight IV - MCBA State Championship Preliminary Contest — Flight IV · 76.864Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight IV · Oct 12, 2024 — Rockford — Flight IV · 72.833Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight IV · Oct 4, 2025 — Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational — Flight IV · 71.5Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight IV · Oct 11, 2025 — Sparta Marching Band Invitational — Flight IV · 74.167Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight I · Oct 7, 2023 — Clarkston Marching Band Invitational — Flight I · 77.5Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight I · Oct 12, 2024 — Rockford — Flight I · 83.167Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight I · Oct 26, 2024 — Flight I - MCBA State Championship Preliminary Contest — Flight I · 84.727Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight I · Oct 4, 2025 — Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational — Flight I · 84Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight I · Oct 11, 2025 — Sparta Marching Band Invitational — Flight I · 77.5Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight V · Oct 7, 2023 — Clarkston Marching Band Invitational — Flight V · 66.75Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight V · Oct 11, 2025 — Sparta Marching Band Invitational — Flight V · 74.929Visual - Individual — Tot — Flight II · Sep 28, 2024 — Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational — Flight II · 71.833Visual - Individual — Tot — Flight III · Sep 28, 2024 — Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational — Flight III · 69Visual - Individual — Tot — Flight IV · Sep 28, 2024 — Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational — Flight IV · 71Visual - Individual — Tot — Flight V · Sep 28, 2024 — Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational — Flight V · 65General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight IV · Oct 26, 2024 — Flight IV - MCBA State Championship Preliminary Contest — Flight IV · 78.583General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight IV · Sep 26, 2026 — Huron Valley Invitational — Flight IV · 69.75General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight IV · Oct 3, 2026 — Grand Blanc Marching Band Invitational — Flight IV · 69General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight I · Sep 26, 2026 — Huron Valley Invitational — Flight I · 76.5General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight II · Sep 26, 2026 — Huron Valley Invitational — Flight II · 71.667General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight II · Oct 3, 2026 — Grand Blanc Marching Band Invitational — Flight II · 68General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight III · Sep 26, 2026 — Huron Valley Invitational — Flight III · 69.5General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight III · Oct 3, 2026 — Grand Blanc Marching Band Invitational — Flight III · 75.5General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight V · Sep 26, 2026 — Huron Valley Invitational — Flight V · 64.5Percent of score type maximum
Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight IIVisual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight IIIVisual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight IVVisual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight IVisual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight VVisual - Individual — Tot — Flight IIVisual - Individual — Tot — Flight IIIVisual - Individual — Tot — Flight IVVisual - Individual — Tot — Flight VGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight IVGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight IGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight IIGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight IIIGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight V

Points are judge averages for each competition and flight. Chart units: Percent of score type maximum. Mixed score types are shown as a percentage of their configured maximum; table values remain score points.

Date / competitionFlightCaption / measureScoresAverageMatchedOther judges' comparison averageMatched difference
Sep 30, 2023
Portage Northern Marching Band Invitational		Flight IIVisual - Ensemble — Tot113.6001 / 114.975-1.375
Sep 30, 2023
Portage Northern Marching Band Invitational		Flight IIIVisual - Ensemble — Tot214.3502 / 215.379-1.029
Sep 30, 2023
Portage Northern Marching Band Invitational		Flight IVVisual - Ensemble — Tot313.4673 / 314.878-1.411
Oct 7, 2023
Clarkston Marching Band Invitational		Flight IVisual - Ensemble — Tot215.5002 / 215.960-0.460
Oct 7, 2023
Clarkston Marching Band Invitational		Flight IIVisual - Ensemble — Tot113.3001 / 113.375-0.075
Oct 7, 2023
Clarkston Marching Band Invitational		Flight IIIVisual - Ensemble — Tot114.9001 / 114.300+0.600
Oct 7, 2023
Clarkston Marching Band Invitational		Flight IVVisual - Ensemble — Tot114.5001 / 114.288+0.213
Oct 7, 2023
Clarkston Marching Band Invitational		Flight VVisual - Ensemble — Tot213.3502 / 213.646-0.296
Oct 28, 2023
Flight IV - MCBA State Championship Preliminary Contest		Flight IVVisual - Ensemble — Tot1115.37311 / 1114.550+0.822
Sep 28, 2024
Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational		Flight IIVisual - Individual — Tot37.1833 / 37.993-0.809
Sep 28, 2024
Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational		Flight IIIVisual - Individual — Tot26.9002 / 27.503-0.603
Sep 28, 2024
Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational		Flight IVVisual - Individual — Tot27.1002 / 27.223-0.123
Sep 28, 2024
Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational		Flight VVisual - Individual — Tot16.5001 / 16.825-0.325
Oct 12, 2024
Rockford		Flight IVisual - Ensemble — Tot316.6333 / 317.144-0.511
Oct 12, 2024
Rockford		Flight IIVisual - Ensemble — Tot315.4003 / 316.400-1.000
Oct 12, 2024
Rockford		Flight IVVisual - Ensemble — Tot614.5676 / 614.654-0.087
Oct 26, 2024
Flight I - MCBA State Championship Preliminary Contest		Flight IVisual - Ensemble — Tot1116.94511 / 1116.495+0.450
Oct 26, 2024
Flight IV - MCBA State Championship Preliminary Contest		Flight IVGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot1215.71712 / 1214.331+1.385
Oct 4, 2025
Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational		Flight IVisual - Ensemble — Tot116.8001 / 117.760-0.960
Oct 4, 2025
Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational		Flight IIVisual - Ensemble — Tot315.7673 / 315.865-0.098
Oct 4, 2025
Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational		Flight IIIVisual - Ensemble — Tot315.1673 / 316.228-1.062
Oct 4, 2025
Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational		Flight IVVisual - Ensemble — Tot314.3003 / 314.983-0.683
Oct 11, 2025
Sparta Marching Band Invitational		Flight IVisual - Ensemble — Tot115.5001 / 116.600-1.100
Oct 11, 2025
Sparta Marching Band Invitational		Flight IIVisual - Ensemble — Tot215.8002 / 216.629-0.829
Oct 11, 2025
Sparta Marching Band Invitational		Flight IIIVisual - Ensemble — Tot415.1634 / 415.829-0.667
Oct 11, 2025
Sparta Marching Band Invitational		Flight IVVisual - Ensemble — Tot314.8333 / 315.353-0.519
Oct 11, 2025
Sparta Marching Band Invitational		Flight VVisual - Ensemble — Tot714.9867 / 715.146-0.161
Sep 26, 2026
Huron Valley Invitational		Flight IGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot215.3002 / 216.583-1.283
Sep 26, 2026
Huron Valley Invitational		Flight IIGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot314.3333 / 315.661-1.328
Sep 26, 2026
Huron Valley Invitational		Flight IIIGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot213.9002 / 215.942-2.042
Sep 26, 2026
Huron Valley Invitational		Flight IVGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot213.9502 / 214.483-0.533
Sep 26, 2026
Huron Valley Invitational		Flight VGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot112.9001 / 113.667-0.767
Oct 3, 2026
Grand Blanc Marching Band Invitational		Flight IIGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot113.6001 / 113.233+0.367
Oct 3, 2026
Grand Blanc Marching Band Invitational		Flight IIIGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot215.1002 / 216.513-1.413
Oct 3, 2026
Grand Blanc Marching Band Invitational		Flight IVGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot313.8003 / 313.967-0.167

Matched difference vs other judges

Matched difference vs other judgesLines show recorded values. Gaps indicate missing scores. Exact values and competition links are in the table below.-11.922-6.781-1.6413.58.641Sep 30, 2023Oct 28, 2023Oct 12, 2024Oct 4, 2025Sep 26, 2026Oct 3, 2026Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight II · Sep 30, 2023 — Portage Northern Marching Band Invitational — Flight II · -6.875Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight II · Oct 7, 2023 — Clarkston Marching Band Invitational — Flight II · -0.375Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight II · Oct 12, 2024 — Rockford — Flight II · -5Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight II · Oct 4, 2025 — Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational — Flight II · -0.492Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight II · Oct 11, 2025 — Sparta Marching Band Invitational — Flight II · -4.146Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight III · Sep 30, 2023 — Portage Northern Marching Band Invitational — Flight III · -5.144Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight III · Oct 7, 2023 — Clarkston Marching Band Invitational — Flight III · 3Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight III · Oct 4, 2025 — Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational — Flight III · -5.309Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight III · Oct 11, 2025 — Sparta Marching Band Invitational — Flight III · -3.333Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight IV · Sep 30, 2023 — Portage Northern Marching Band Invitational — Flight IV · -7.056Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight IV · Oct 7, 2023 — Clarkston Marching Band Invitational — Flight IV · 1.063Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight IV · Oct 28, 2023 — Flight IV - MCBA State Championship Preliminary Contest — Flight IV · 4.112Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight IV · Oct 12, 2024 — Rockford — Flight IV · -0.436Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight IV · Oct 4, 2025 — Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational — Flight IV · -3.417Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight IV · Oct 11, 2025 — Sparta Marching Band Invitational — Flight IV · -2.597Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight I · Oct 7, 2023 — Clarkston Marching Band Invitational — Flight I · -2.3Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight I · Oct 12, 2024 — Rockford — Flight I · -2.556Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight I · Oct 26, 2024 — Flight I - MCBA State Championship Preliminary Contest — Flight I · 2.25Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight I · Oct 4, 2025 — Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational — Flight I · -4.8Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight I · Oct 11, 2025 — Sparta Marching Band Invitational — Flight I · -5.5Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight V · Oct 7, 2023 — Clarkston Marching Band Invitational — Flight V · -1.479Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight V · Oct 11, 2025 — Sparta Marching Band Invitational — Flight V · -0.804Visual - Individual — Tot — Flight II · Sep 28, 2024 — Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational — Flight II · -8.092Visual - Individual — Tot — Flight III · Sep 28, 2024 — Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational — Flight III · -6.031Visual - Individual — Tot — Flight IV · Sep 28, 2024 — Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational — Flight IV · -1.229Visual - Individual — Tot — Flight V · Sep 28, 2024 — Lake Orion Marching Band Invitational — Flight V · -3.25General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight IV · Oct 26, 2024 — Flight IV - MCBA State Championship Preliminary Contest — Flight IV · 6.927General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight IV · Sep 26, 2026 — Huron Valley Invitational — Flight IV · -2.667General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight IV · Oct 3, 2026 — Grand Blanc Marching Band Invitational — Flight IV · -0.833General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight I · Sep 26, 2026 — Huron Valley Invitational — Flight I · -6.417General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight II · Sep 26, 2026 — Huron Valley Invitational — Flight II · -6.639General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight II · Oct 3, 2026 — Grand Blanc Marching Band Invitational — Flight II · 1.833General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight III · Sep 26, 2026 — Huron Valley Invitational — Flight III · -10.208General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight III · Oct 3, 2026 — Grand Blanc Marching Band Invitational — Flight III · -7.063General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight V · Sep 26, 2026 — Huron Valley Invitational — Flight V · -3.833Other-judge reference (zero) · Sep 30, 2023 · 0Other-judge reference (zero) · Oct 7, 2023 · 0Other-judge reference (zero) · Oct 28, 2023 · 0Other-judge reference (zero) · Sep 28, 2024 · 0Other-judge reference (zero) · Oct 12, 2024 · 0Other-judge reference (zero) · Oct 26, 2024 · 0Other-judge reference (zero) · Oct 4, 2025 · 0Other-judge reference (zero) · Oct 11, 2025 · 0Other-judge reference (zero) · Sep 26, 2026 · 0Other-judge reference (zero) · Oct 3, 2026 · 0Percentage points of score type maximum
Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight IIVisual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight IIIVisual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight IVVisual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight IVisual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight VVisual - Individual — Tot — Flight IIVisual - Individual — Tot — Flight IIIVisual - Individual — Tot — Flight IVVisual - Individual — Tot — Flight VGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight IVGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight IGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight IIGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight IIIGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight VOther-judge reference (zero)

Below zero means lower than the same schools' other-judge averages; above zero means higher. Missing comparisons remain gaps. Units: Percentage points of score type maximum. Interpret differences alongside sample coverage, band improvement, and competition conditions.

Year-over-year — Pickett, Dave

The same caption, measure, flight, and exhibition filters apply across all years.

YearCaption / measureScoresAverageHighLowMatchedDifference
2026General Effect - Visual — Tot1614.21315.70012.80016 / 16-0.964
2025Visual - Ensemble — Tot2715.17216.90013.50027 / 27-0.541
2024General Effect - Visual — Tot1215.71717.00014.10012 / 12+1.385
2024Visual - Ensemble — Tot2316.08318.70013.60023 / 23-0.005
2024Visual - Individual — Tot87.0067.5006.5008 / 8-0.526
2023Visual - Ensemble — Tot2414.67517.10012.80024 / 24+0.025