SCORING TRENDS

Judge statistics

Compare a band with a judge

Recorded scores34
Scored competitions3
Schools33

Only scores tied to a matching judge assignment are included; penalties are excluded. Each row compares one caption and score type, using score points. Select a caption and flight to narrow the comparison.

Difference vs other judges: for each score, compare with other judges' scores for the same school, score type, year, flight, and competitive/exhibition status at other competitions. Negative means lower than that comparison average. Matched count shows how many scores have a comparison. These describe the recorded performances; improvement over the season and different competition conditions also affect scores.

JudgeCaption / measureMaximumScoresShows / schoolsAverageHighLowMatchedDifference vs other judges
Carlisle, J.General Effect - Visual — Tot20222 / 2215.74117.20014.10022 / 22+0.241
Carlisle, J.Visual - Ensemble — Tot20121 / 1215.97517.50013.80012 / 12+0.599

Carlisle, J. · competition trends

Judge averages by competition and flightLines show recorded values. Gaps indicate missing scores. Exact values and competition links are in the table below.77.68278.35579.02879.70280.375Oct 28, 2023Oct 25, 2025General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight IV · Oct 28, 2023 — Flight IV - MCBA State Championship Preliminary Contest — Flight IV · 79.227General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight I · Oct 25, 2025 — Flight I - MCBA State Championship Preliminary Contest — Flight I · 78.182Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight III · Oct 25, 2025 — Flight III - MCBA State Championship Preliminary Contest — Flight III · 79.875Percent of score type maximum
General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight IVGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight IVisual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight III

Points are judge averages for each competition and flight. Chart units: Percent of score type maximum. Mixed score types are shown as a percentage of their configured maximum; table values remain score points.

Date / competitionFlightCaption / measureScoresAverageMatchedOther judges' comparison averageMatched difference
Oct 28, 2023
Flight IV - MCBA State Championship Preliminary Contest		Flight IVGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot1115.84511 / 1114.208+1.638
Oct 25, 2025
Flight I - MCBA State Championship Preliminary Contest		Flight IGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot1115.63611 / 1116.793-1.157
Oct 25, 2025
Flight III - MCBA State Championship Preliminary Contest		Flight IIIVisual - Ensemble — Tot1215.97512 / 1215.376+0.599

Matched difference vs other judges

Matched difference vs other judgesLines show recorded values. Gaps indicate missing scores. Exact values and competition links are in the table below.-7.181-2.9891.2035.3959.587Oct 28, 2023Oct 25, 2025General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight IV · Oct 28, 2023 — Flight IV - MCBA State Championship Preliminary Contest — Flight IV · 8.189General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight I · Oct 25, 2025 — Flight I - MCBA State Championship Preliminary Contest — Flight I · -5.784Visual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight III · Oct 25, 2025 — Flight III - MCBA State Championship Preliminary Contest — Flight III · 2.995Other-judge reference (zero) · Oct 28, 2023 · 0Other-judge reference (zero) · Oct 25, 2025 · 0Percentage points of score type maximum
General Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight IVGeneral Effect - Visual — Tot — Flight IVisual - Ensemble — Tot — Flight IIIOther-judge reference (zero)

Below zero means lower than the same schools' other-judge averages; above zero means higher. Missing comparisons remain gaps. Units: Percentage points of score type maximum. Interpret differences alongside sample coverage, band improvement, and competition conditions.

Year-over-year — Carlisle, J.

The same caption, measure, flight, and exhibition filters apply across all years.

YearCaption / measureScoresAverageHighLowMatchedDifference
2025General Effect - Visual — Tot1115.63617.10014.10011 / 11-1.157
2025Visual - Ensemble — Tot1215.97517.50013.80012 / 12+0.599
2023General Effect - Visual — Tot1115.84517.20014.10011 / 11+1.638